L'Hopital's Rule Free Response Solutions (Part 2), Calculus III – Study Notes
offline

Difficulty: Advanced | Prerequisites: Core concepts study notes, Part 1 solutions, differential equations, Euler's method

Problems 19 to 21

Problem 19: lim (t to infinity) of sin(1/t) / ln t

As t goes to infinity, sin(1/t) approaches sin(0) = 0, and ln t goes to infinity. The form is 0/infinity, which equals 0. This is not indeterminate.

Answer: 0


Problem 20: lim (v to infinity) of v^2 / e^(-v)

Rewrite e^(-v) = 1/e^v. So the expression is v^2 times e^v, which is infinity times infinity = infinity. This is not indeterminate.

Alternatively, written as v^2 / e^(-v) = v^2 times e^v. Both factors grow without bound.

Answer: positive infinity


Problem 21: lim (x to 0+) of [x^2 times sin(1/x)] / sin x

This requires careful handling. sin(1/x) oscillates between -1 and 1 as x approaches 0, so x^2 times sin(1/x) is bounded between -x^2 and x^2, both of which go to 0.

Meanwhile sin x goes to 0 as x goes to 0. So we have the form 0/0, but L'Hopital's Rule is problematic here because the derivative of sin(1/x) does not behave well.

Instead, rewrite: [x^2 sin(1/x)] / sin x = [x^2 sin(1/x) / x] times [x / sin x].

The second factor, x / sin x, goes to 1.

The first factor is x times sin(1/x). Since sin(1/x) is bounded between -1 and 1, this is squeezed between -x and x, which both go to 0. By the Squeeze Theorem, x sin(1/x) goes to 0.

The product is 0 times 1 = 0.

Answer: 0

Problems 22 to 24

Problem 22: lim (u to 0+) of (2^u minus 1) times sqrt(u)

As u goes to 0+, 2^u minus 1 goes to 0 and sqrt(u) goes to 0. The form is 0 times 0, which is simply 0. No L'Hopital's Rule needed.

Answer: 0


Problem 23: lim (x to infinity) of (ln|2x minus 4| minus ln|x + 3|)

Combine the logarithms: ln|(2x minus 4) / (x + 3)|.

Evaluate the inside: (2x - 4)/(x + 3). Divide numerator and denominator by x: (2 - 4/x) / (1 + 3/x). As x goes to infinity, this approaches 2/1 = 2.

So the limit is ln|2| = ln 2.

Answer: ln 2


Problem 24: lim (theta to 0) of pi^2 times tan(2 theta) / (theta times cos(2 theta))

Direct substitution gives 0/0 (the pi^2 is a constant factor, tan(2 theta) goes to 0, and theta goes to 0, while cos(2 theta) goes to 1).

Simplify: pi^2 times [tan(2 theta) / theta] times [1 / cos(2 theta)].

The factor 1/cos(2 theta) goes to 1/1 = 1.

For tan(2 theta) / theta: this is sin(2 theta) / (theta times cos(2 theta)). Apply L'Hopital's Rule to sin(2 theta) / theta (form 0/0):

  • d/d(theta)[sin(2 theta)] = 2 cos(2 theta)

  • d/d(theta)[theta] = 1

The limit is 2 cos(0) = 2.

Combining everything: pi^2 times 2 times 1 = 2 pi^2.

Answer: 2 pi^2

Problem 25 (AP 2010-5)

Given: dy/dx = 1 minus y, with f(1) = 0 and f(x) < 1 for all x.

Part (a): Euler's method to approximate f(0)

Starting at x = 1, two steps of equal size to reach x = 0. Step size h = (0 minus 1)/2 = -1/2.

Step 1: At (1, 0), dy/dx = 1 minus 0 = 1. New y = 0 + (-1/2)(1) = -1/2. New point: (1/2, -1/2).

Step 2: At (1/2, -1/2), dy/dx = 1 minus (-1/2) = 3/2. New y = -1/2 + (-1/2)(3/2) = -1/2 minus 3/4 = -5/4. New point: (0, -5/4).

f(0) is approximately -5/4.

Part (b): Find lim (x to 1) of f(x) / (x^3 minus 1)

Since f(1) = 0 and x^3 minus 1 = 0 when x = 1, this is 0/0. Apply L'Hopital's Rule.

Numerator derivative: f'(x). From the differential equation, f'(x) = 1 minus f(x). At x = 1: f'(1) = 1 minus 0 = 1.

Denominator derivative: 3x^2. At x = 1: 3(1)^2 = 3.

The limit is 1/3.

Part (c): Solve the differential equation

dy/dx = 1 minus y is a separable equation.

Separate: dy / (1 minus y) = dx.

Integrate both sides: -ln|1 minus y| = x + C.

So ln|1 minus y| = -x minus C.

|1 minus y| = e^(-x minus C) = Ae^(-x) where A = e^(-C).

Since f(x) < 1 for all x, we have 1 minus y > 0, so 1 minus y = Ae^(-x).

Apply initial condition f(1) = 0: 1 minus 0 = Ae^(-1), so A = e.

1 minus y = e times e^(-x) = e^(1-x).

y = 1 minus e^(1-x).

f(x) = 1 minus e^(1 minus x)

Problem 26 (2016-BC4)

Given: dy/dx = x^2 minus (1/2)y.

Part (a): Find d^2y/dx^2 in terms of x and y

Differentiate dy/dx = x^2 minus (1/2)y with respect to x:

d^2y/dx^2 = 2x minus (1/2)(dy/dx) = 2x minus (1/2)(x^2 minus (1/2)y) = 2x minus (1/2)x^2 + (1/4)y.

d^2y/dx^2 = 2x minus (1/2)x^2 + (1/4)y

Part (b): Relative extremum at (-2, 8)

Check dy/dx at (-2, 8): (-2)^2 minus (1/2)(8) = 4 minus 4 = 0. So there is a critical point.

Check d^2y/dx^2 at (-2, 8): 2(-2) minus (1/2)(4) + (1/4)(8) = -4 minus 2 + 2 = -4.

Since d^2y/dx^2 < 0, the graph has a relative maximum at (-2, 8) by the Second Derivative Test.

Part (c): Find lim (x to -1) of [g(x) minus 2] / [3(x + 1)^2], where g(-1) = 2

At x = -1: g(-1) = 2, so the numerator is 0. The denominator 3(x+1)^2 is also 0. Form is 0/0.

Apply L'Hopital's Rule: g'(x) / [6(x + 1)].

At x = -1: g'(-1) = (-1)^2 minus (1/2)(2) = 1 minus 1 = 0. Still 0/0.

Apply L'Hopital's Rule again: g''(x) / 6.

At x = -1: g''(-1) = 2(-1) minus (1/2)(1) + (1/4)(2) = -2 minus 1/2 + 1/2 = -2.

The limit is -2/6 = -1/3.

Answer: -1/3

Part (d): Euler's method / Linearisation with h(0) = 2

BC version (Euler's method): Starting at x = 0, two steps of size 1/2 to reach x = 1.

Step 1: At (0, 2), dy/dx = 0 minus (1/2)(2) = -1. New y = 2 + (1/2)(-1) = 3/2. New point: (1/2, 3/2).

Step 2: At (1/2, 3/2), dy/dx = 1/4 minus (1/2)(3/2) = 1/4 minus 3/4 = -1/2. New y = 3/2 + (1/2)(-1/2) = 3/2 minus 1/4 = 5/4. New point: (1, 5/4).

h(1) is approximately 5/4.

AB version (Linearisation): At x = 0, h(0) = 2 and h'(0) = 0 minus (1/2)(2) = -1.

The linearisation is L(x) = 2 + (-1)(x minus 0) = 2 minus x.

L(1) = 2 minus 1 = 1.

h(1) is approximately 1.

Key Takeaways

  • Not every limit needs L'Hopital's Rule. Problems 19, 20, and 22 resolve without it because the form is not indeterminate (0/infinity, infinity times infinity, 0 times 0). Identifying the form first saves time and avoids errors.

  • The Squeeze Theorem (Problem 21) is a valuable alternative when derivatives are messy or undefined. If an oscillating factor is bounded and multiplied by something going to zero, squeeze it.

  • Logarithm properties (Problem 23) let you sidestep L'Hopital's Rule entirely. When two logs are subtracted, combine them into one and evaluate the argument's limit.

  • AP free-response problems (25 and 26) test L'Hopital's Rule alongside differential equations. The key move is using dy/dx = F(x, y) to find f'(a) from the DE rather than solving the DE first. For part (c) of Problem 26, you need the second derivative, which means differentiating the DE with respect to x (using implicit differentiation via the chain rule on the y term).

  • Euler's method questions pair naturally with L'Hopital's Rule on the AP exam. Both appear in the same free-response problem, testing whether you can switch between numerical approximation and analytical limit evaluation.